Citation:
Adapted from: Beyond Personality: The Impact of GMA on Performance for Entry-Level Service Employees, Journal of Service Management.

‍

Introduction: Rethinking Talent in Entry-Level Service Roles

‍

Service industries are the backbone of customer satisfaction, relying heavily on entry-level employees to deliver quality experiences. Traditionally, hiring decisions have emphasized personality traits to predict success in these roles. But new research suggests a game-changing factor—General Mental Ability (GMA)—can be a stronger predictor of job performance.

‍

In "Beyond Personality: The Impact of GMA on Performance for Entry-Level Service Employees," published in the Journal of Service Management, researchers explore how GMA surpasses personality traits in predicting entry-level performance. This blog delves into the findings and provides actionable strategies for HR leaders to improve hiring and retention practices.

‍

What is General Mental Ability (GMA)?

‍

GMA, often referred to as cognitive ability, is the capacity to learn, reason, and solve problems. It encompasses skills like critical thinking, numerical reasoning, and verbal comprehension. Unlike personality traits, which describe behavioral tendencies, GMA predicts how effectively someone can process information and adapt to new tasks.

‍

Why GMA matters:

• Learning Agility: High-GMA employees quickly grasp new processes, making training faster and more effective.
• Problem Solving: Strong cognitive skills enable employees to handle unexpected challenges.
• Role Flexibility: Employees with higher GMA adapt more easily to evolving job requirements.

‍

In entry-level service roles, these qualities are particularly valuable, where fast learning and adaptability directly impact customer satisfaction.

‍

Key Findings: GMA vs. Personality in Predicting Job Performance

‍

The study compared the predictive power of GMA and personality traits for job performance. While personality traits like conscientiousness and agreeableness remain important, GMA was found to be the strongest predictor of overall success in entry-level service roles.

‍

Highlights from the findings:

• Learning and Adaptation: GMA explained a significant portion of performance variance in roles requiring frequent training and skill application.
• Task Efficiency: High-GMA employees completed tasks faster and with fewer errors.
• Customer Interaction: Employees with higher cognitive ability were better at resolving complex customer issues.

‍

While personality assessments remain a valuable tool for evaluating culture fit and interpersonal skills, incorporating cognitive assessments provides a more holistic approach to employee selection.

‍

The Complementary Role of Personality and GMA Assessments

‍

Personality and GMA assessments are not mutually exclusive. Instead, they complement each other to provide a fuller picture of a candidate's potential.

• GMA assesses trainability, adaptability, and cognitive problem-solving.
• Personality predicts interpersonal skills, stress tolerance, and cultural alignment.

‍

Practical Application: Use a two-step approach in employee selection:

• Initial Screening: Begin with personality assessments to identify candidates aligned with your organizational culture.
• Cognitive Assessment: Follow up with GMA evaluations to ensure candidates can perform complex, adaptive tasks effectively.

‍

This combination optimizes the hiring process, balancing technical proficiency with behavioral compatibility.

‍

Practical Recommendations for Hiring

‍

HR leaders can apply these insights to refine their hiring strategies for entry-level service employees.

‍

• Invest in Cognitive Assessments: Use validated tools like Wonderlic or Criteria Corp’s CCAT to evaluate GMA.
• Role-Specific Benchmarks: Establish minimum GMA thresholds tailored to job requirements.
• Combine with Personality Metrics: Ensure candidates also exhibit traits like agreeableness and conscientiousness for customer-facing roles.

‍

Example: For a customer service representative, you might prioritize high scores in verbal reasoning (GMA) alongside agreeableness and emotional stability (personality).

‍

‍

Training and Development for High-GMA Employees

‍

Once hired, employees with high GMA require tailored training strategies to unlock their full potential.

• Accelerated Learning Programs: High-GMA employees thrive in fast-paced, intensive training environments.
• Role Rotation: Provide opportunities to learn multiple functions, leveraging their adaptability.
• Problem-Solving Challenges: Incorporate real-world scenarios into training to sharpen critical thinking.

‍

These strategies not only enhance individual performance but also contribute to team productivity and innovation.

Reducing Turnover with Cognitive Insights

‍

High turnover rates in entry-level service roles are a costly problem for many organizations. The study highlights how GMA assessments can help reduce turnover by identifying candidates who are more likely to succeed and remain engaged in their roles.

‍

How GMA reduces turnover:

• Job Fit: High-GMA candidates align better with role demands, leading to higher satisfaction.
• Growth Opportunities: Cognitive assessments help identify employees who can transition to advanced roles, improving retention.

‍

Organizations that invest in predictive assessments report fewer bad hires, lower recruitment costs, and longer employee tenure.

‍

Recommendations for Implementation

‍

To successfully integrate GMA assessments into your hiring and talent management processes, consider these best practices:

• Partner with Assessment Providers: Companies like Criteria Corp and SHL offer GMA tests tailored for various industries.
• Educate Hiring Managers: Train managers to interpret GMA scores alongside personality profiles.
• Pilot and Measure: Start with a pilot program, tracking performance outcomes to validate effectiveness.

‍

Additionally, refer to resources like Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology (SIOP) for guidelines on ethical and effective assessment use.

‍

GMA and the Future of Employee Selection

‍

The findings from this study point to a broader trend in talent acquisition: the increasing emphasis on cognitive ability as a key driver of success. While personality remains a critical factor, GMA offers a predictive edge for identifying high-potential employees.

‍

Organizations that embrace this approach will:

• Improve hiring precision.
• Reduce turnover and training costs.
• Build more adaptable and capable teams.

‍

As the service industry continues to evolve, leveraging both GMA and personality assessments will be essential for staying competitive.

‍

Conclusion: Building Smarter Teams with GMA

‍

The study, "Beyond Personality: The Impact of GMA on Performance for Entry-Level Service Employees," highlights the value of cognitive ability in predicting job success. By incorporating GMA assessments into hiring and development processes, organizations can unlock significant performance gains, reduce turnover, and enhance employee satisfaction.

‍

Citation:
Adapted from: Beyond Personality: The Impact of GMA on Performance for Entry-Level Service Employees, Journal of Service Management.

‍

‍

Ready to transform your hiring process? 

‍

Explore how personality assessments can help you build and retain high-performing restaurant teams. Contact us today to learn more.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍